Today’s Newsday Saturday Stumper, by David P. Williams, is, to my mind, the best Stumper in many weeks. Difficult as #@&! and hugely satisfying to solve. I began with a gimme, 41-A, nine letters, “‘Break me off a piece’ snack.” The clue that began to break things open: 26-D, seven letters, “Among the top-five fastest production cars (270+ mph.)” I don’t know how the answer popped into my head.
There’s a convention of crossword construction that a word used as an answer should not appear in a clue for another answer. This puzzle breaks with that convention. But it’s okay by me.
Some clue-and-answer pairs of note:
1-A, eight letters, “Surname like Newhouse.” Starting off with a bang.
5-D, ten letters, “It’s ‘between theology and science,’ per Bertrand Russell.” The obvious answer, PHILOSOPHY, won’t work.
7-D, seven letters, “Escape route.” I’ve used it, often.
9-D, five letters, “French English affectation.” Clever.
12-D, eight letters, “Don’t hold back.” Williams’s Stumpers seem to always include a dowdy colloquialism. I like that.
23-A, five letters, “Mark on the curve.” Takes me back, but not to a classroom.
33-A, six letters, “Turkey topper.” GRAVY doesn’t fit.
35-D, eight letters, “Loudspeaker’s moving part.” A word I haven’t thought of in years.
39-D, seven letters, “Start to chase.” Crosses needed.
50-A, seven letters, “Subject of the Masakela song ‘Bring Him Back Home’ (1987).” No crosses needed.
56-D, three letters, “ Things Considered (bird blog).” Smiles.
My favorite in this puzzle: 30-A, four letters, “Personal space.” True that.
No spoilers; the answers are in the comments.