Three weeks after publication, a factual error in the New York Times obituary for Joyce Randolph stands uncorrected:
As Trixie, Ms. Randolph played the upstairs wife who crossed her arms and commiserated with her best friend, Alice, over addlepated husbands who somehow got drunk on grape juice, found a suitcase of the mob’s counterfeit cash, invented a “handy” kitchen tool that could “core a apple” and, after waiting all year for the convention of their International Order of Friendly Raccoons, took the wrong train.
Those choice — or, in Brooklynese, cherce — details make me think that the writer, Robert D. McFadden, loves
The Honeymooners , so much so that he may have been writing from memory. But in the
Honeymooners episode “Better Living Through TV” (November 12, 1955), Ralph and Ed do not invent the Handy Housewife Helper. The brother of one of Ralph’s fellow bus drivers has a Bronx warehouse in which someone left 2,000 of the gadgets. Ralph and Ed buy the lot for $200 and try to sell them via a television commercial.
I’ve written to the
Times twice about the error. I included
a link to the episode at Dailymotion, pointing out where the relevant dialogue may be found (at the 3:35 mark). Still no correction.
As Edward L. Norton might say, Sheesh.
*
July 19, 2024: I wrote to the
Times again yesterday, and this time I received a non-automated reply. Long story short: the error will stand. The person who wrote says that the
Times can correct errors if they’re pointed out in “a reasonable amount of time.” After that, errors stand, as the paper lacks to resources to to “re-report” old articles. The writer also noted that the
Times never heard from me before yesterday.
In reponse, I sent screenshots of previous e-mails to and automated replies from NYT Corrections (January 14 and February 3). I also pointed out that changing one word — changing
invented to, say,
marketed, is hardly a matter of re-reporting an article. No reply.
As Edward L. Norton might say, Sheesh.
Related reading
All OCA
Honeymooners posts (Pinboard)