Alice James, in a diary entry dated January 6, 1892:
It is reassuring to hear the English pronouncement that Emily Dickinson is fifth-rate — they have such a capacity for missing quality; the robust evades them equally with the subtle. Her being sicklied o’er with T.W. Higginson makes one quake lest there be a latent flaw which escapes one’s vision.Long before I kept a blog, I kept a commonplace book, writing out passages of all sorts by hand. I found these sentences quoted in a letter from Lorine Niedecker to fellow poet Louis Zukofsky, February 14, 1952. I just checked, and the quotation is accurate.
I mean no disrespect to “the English.” It’s the idea of disapproval as a mark of high quality that amuses me.
Related reading
All OCA Dickinson posts (Pinboard)
[For Thomas Wentworth Higginson, see here.]