Last night I tried to imagine what my friend Rob Zseleczky might have said about about the traces of CliffsNotes and SparkNotes in Bob Dylan’s Nobel Prize lecture. “He’s an outlaw, Michael,” I imagined Rob saying. “He doesn’t care what you think of him.” And then I imagined Rob laughing helplessly: “CliffsNotes!”
skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Michael Leddy“Orange Crate Art” is a song by Van Dyke Parks and the title of a 1995 album by Van Dyke Parks and Brian Wilson. “Orange Crate Art” is for me one of the great American songs: “Orange crate art was a place to start.”
Don’t look for premiums or
coupons, as the cost of
the thoughts blended in
ORANGE CRATE ART pro-
hibits the use of them.
Comments are welcome, appended to posts or by e-mail. I moderate comments to keep out spam, so please be patient.
View Profile
Nancy, October 19, 1950.
“Who are we as a country?”
Michael Leddy
Don’t look for premiums or
coupons, as the cost of
the thoughts blended in
ORANGE CRATE ART pro-
hibits the use of them.
Comments are welcome, appended to posts or by e-mail. I moderate comments to keep out spam, so please be patient.
Search this blog
Creative Commons
StatCounter
Subscribe
Click to subscribe in a reader.
Top twenty tags
Words to live by
Life is to be lived, not controlled; and humanity is won by continuing to play in the face of certain defeat.
Ralph Ellison, Invisible Man
*
Νέος ἐφ’ ἡμέρῃ ἥλιος. [The sun is new every day.]
Heraclitus
*
Every day is a new deal.
Harvey Pekar, “Alice Quinn”
*
Nos plus grandes craintes, comme nos plus grandes espérances, ne sont pas au-dessus de nos forces, et nous pouvons finir par dominer les unes et réaliser les autres. [Our worst fears, like our greatest hopes, are not outside our powers, and we can come in the end to triumph over the former and to achieve the latter.]
Marcel Proust, Finding Time Again
*
Surely, in the light of history, it is more intelligent to hope rather than to fear, to try rather than not to try.
Eleanor Roosevelt, You Learn by Living
*
I don’t really deeply feel that anyone needs an airtight reason for quoting from the works of writers he loves, but it’s always nice, I’ll grant you, if he has one.
J.D. Salinger, Seymour: An Introduction
*
I’m not afraid to get it right
I turn around and I give it
one more try
Sufjan Stevens, “Jacksonville”
*
L’attention est la forme la plus rare et la plus pure de la générosité. [Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity.]
Simone Weil, in a letter
Ralph Ellison, Invisible Man
*
Νέος ἐφ’ ἡμέρῃ ἥλιος. [The sun is new every day.]
Heraclitus
*
Every day is a new deal.
Harvey Pekar, “Alice Quinn”
*
Nos plus grandes craintes, comme nos plus grandes espérances, ne sont pas au-dessus de nos forces, et nous pouvons finir par dominer les unes et réaliser les autres. [Our worst fears, like our greatest hopes, are not outside our powers, and we can come in the end to triumph over the former and to achieve the latter.]
Marcel Proust, Finding Time Again
*
Surely, in the light of history, it is more intelligent to hope rather than to fear, to try rather than not to try.
Eleanor Roosevelt, You Learn by Living
*
I don’t really deeply feel that anyone needs an airtight reason for quoting from the works of writers he loves, but it’s always nice, I’ll grant you, if he has one.
J.D. Salinger, Seymour: An Introduction
*
I’m not afraid to get it right
I turn around and I give it
one more try
Sufjan Stevens, “Jacksonville”
*
L’attention est la forme la plus rare et la plus pure de la générosité. [Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity.]
Simone Weil, in a letter
#1 hit
In memory of
Blog Archive
-
▼
2017
(929)
-
▼
June
(70)
- “Dedicado à Você”
- Illinois, Illinois, Illinois
- Recently updated
- Pocket notebook sightings
- Overheard
- A p@ge-ninety test
- Used-book-store score
- In search of fake Time
- Balzac, speculating
- Earl Greyer, correcter
- Henry TV
- Roscoe Mitchell in TNYT
- “The old-school landline telephone”
- Mystery actor
- Handwritten letters, 25¢ each
- Alain de Botton on academia
- Fred Stein photography
- Pogie the porcupine
- Animal Lending Library
- Republicans present and past
- Lost thoughts
- Watching Lost in five sentences
- “Once Per Day”
- Lawn mower troubleshooting
- How do you say “crazy, harebrained scheme” in French?
- White House misspellings and typos
- Domestic comedy
- A joke in the traditional manner
- Music for Father’s Day
- A Henry insult
- Woodstock TV
- Word of the night: owl-hoot
- Lost Ulysses
- Bloomsday 2017
- WWRZS
- Dylan, Homer, and Cliff
- La Quiberonnaise sardines
- Time travel
- Milk as safe
- Workplace expression of the day
- Coffee-and
- Ambiguous headline
- Coffee and other grandest things
- Aldi on the move
- On hope
- Roscoe Mitchell at Mills
- “Hysteria over hyphens”
- Two photographs
- Chris Sippel (1956–2017)
- Into the frying pan
- Domestic comedy
- Peanuts Donald
- “Salacious material”
- “Sgt. Petsound’s”
- Too many ands?
- Efficiency and effectiveness
- “Fact from Fiction”
- Anil Dash on choices
- A page-forty-five test
- Dylan and Homer
- At least eleven more movies
- Dirt Sounds
- From the Saturday Stumper
- Some rocks, some clouds
- Overheard
- Pinboard buys Delicious
- "Always standing around everywhere and butting in”
- Goodbye to Paris
- Junk mail
- “Don’t fucking kill yourself”
-
▼
June
(70)
favorite posts
- Against “deep reading”
- Alkalize with Alka-Seltzer
- At the World Trade Center and St. Paul’s Chapel
- Being wrong about beauty
- Bobbing for apples
- “Bon Appétit!”
- “The Case of the Purloined Prairie”
- ChatGPT’s twenty-line poems
- “The ’Clipse”
- Couric and Palin and Orwell
- Digital naïfs
- Donald Trump’s spelling
- Ebinger’s
- Ellington for beginners
- “Extra credit?”
- Five desks
- Five pens
- Fluke life
- The gold standard, haircuts, and everyone else
- Happy birthday, Mr. Piletti
- Hoagies, pizza, and English studies
- Homeric blindness in “colledge”
- How to Write a Sentence
- Imaginary liner notes
- Invisible man: Louis Armstrong and the New York Times
- Invitation to a dance
- Is there a pencil in The House?
- John Lee Hooker and Canned Heat
- A Kerouac notebook page
- The kitchen shink [sic]
- Klenosky!
- “Make My Jotter Quit!”
- Lady Elaine’s can
- Mysteries of the tollbooth
- National’s et cetera
- Nick DeMaio and the Eldorado
- Obama revisions
- Obama thoughts
- On “On the New Literacy”
- On “Politics and the English Language”
- “On the Road”
- The Oteris and Marty
- The other little book
- Out of the past
- Peppa Pig and the Brontës
- Phones Are For People
- Politics and theory
- “The Poet”
- Proust: involuntary memory, foolish things
- P.S. 131
- Pullum on Strunk and White
- Re: the Beloit Mindset List
- Some have gone and some remain
- “The Spokesmen”
- Sports Illustrated and Proust
- The Springfield Daily Gazette
- That (in)famous line
- Things I learned on my summer vacation
- Van Dyke Parks in Chicago
- W(h)ither grammar
- What I hear in “Walk Away Renee”
Nancy, October 19, 1950.
comments: 2
I think an enormous majority of the public would think that any of us who have a problem with the plagiarized origins of those flimsy-yet-labored sentences in Dylan's remarks are compete pedants. Without knowing even knowing the word "pedant". Too much negativity bias from my brain?
No, I don’t think it’s too much negativity. A good number of the comments at Slate say, more or less, “So what?” But what Dylan did in his lecture isn’t a matter of folk tradition, nor is it a matter of modernist collage. It’s the same thing that some high-school and college students do. If he’d been a student in one of my classes, I’d give him the option to drop, and I’d be sending a report over to Student Affairs. If this be pedantry, make the most of it. :)
Post a Comment