Thursday, October 19, 2023

No free will?

Stanford University neurobiologist Robert Sapolsky says that there’s no such thing as free will:

“The world is really screwed up and made much, much more unfair by the fact that we reward people and punish people for things they have no control over,” Sapolsky said. “We’ve got no free will. Stop attributing stuff to us that isn’t there.”
Well, he had to say that, right?

But seriously: if Sapolsky is right, then my agreeing or disagreeing with him is beyond my control. Which, I think, makes it impossible for his assertion to lay any claim to be true. Because if I agreed with him, then I, too, had to say that.

*

Another thought: Imagine that someone makes a statment x because of an electrical impulse sent through a wire attached to their body. And imagine that other people then say x or not-x because of wires attached to their bodies. If x and the responses to it are beyond our control, what does that do to the idea of truth?

[I have long leaned toward the idea of truth as contingent — contingent and real. That has something to do with my response to Sapolsky.]

comments: 6

Geo-B said...

We must believe in free will, we have no choice.

Isaac Bashevis Singer

Michael Leddy said...

I like that.

Joe DiBiase said...

If there is no free will (I disagree, btw), and we continue to punish people for wrongs over which they had no control, we too have no control in choosing to punish them.

Michael Leddy said...

Nice point!

J D Lowe said...

When we were out and about today we drove by a mega funeral home and cemetery on the outskirts of town. The sign out front said, "Free Will Kits Available." Apparently free will is now available in a convenient kit form :-)

Michael Leddy said...

It makes sense that it would be a do-it-yourself project. : )